Response to 2021 Speech from the Throne
On November 23, 2021 the Right Honorable Governor General Mary Simon delivered the Speech from the Crown (you can read a copy of the speech here). We have written a response, which was sent to the Right Honorable Minister of Women and Gender Equality Marci Ien. Below is the text of the document, which can be downloaded here.
Introduction We carefully read the Speech from the Throne, delivered on November 23, 2021 by the Right Honourable Governor General Mary Simon. This is our brief response to the aspects of the speech that directly impact females. Given the complexity of all three issues: femicide and violence against women and girls; criminal justice reforms; and missing and murdered Indigenous women and girls— we have included additional resources at the end of our response. Femicide and Violence Against Women and Girls First, we appreciate that the government is acknowledging that Canada has a problem with violence against women and girls. We specifically applaud the government for noting the fact that violence against women and girls has increased throughout the pandemic. In 2020 alone, 160 females died in violent attacks, 86% of which confirmed to be committed by males (though 17 cases did not publicly identify an accused) "When accused identified (N=143), the deaths of 128 women and girls involved a male accused (90%)” (“Call It Femicide”, p. 7 and 14). The Ontario Association of Interval and Transition Houses, which represents over 70% of shelters in Ontario, reported that 20% of its shelters had an increase in crisis calls, while the Vancouver-based Battered Women’s Support Services reported a 300% increase in crisis calls. 40% of the calls were from first time callers (“Violence Against Women in Canada & COVID-19 Pandemic”, p. 2). In order to properly address this deadly problem, it is clear that the government must recognize and name male violence as a pervasive issue in our country, and put in place real, markable, annually publicly reported actions to counteract male violence against women and girls within the 10-year National Action Plan. One cannot address a problem without being able to speak of it clearly. The Ontario Association of Interval and Transition Houses, which represents over 70% of shelters in Ontario, reported that 20% of its shelters had an increase in crisis calls, while the Vancouver-based Battered Women’s Support Services reported a 300% increase in crisis calls. 40% of the calls were from first time callers (“Violence Against Women in Canada & COVID-19 Pandemic”, p. 2) The government needs to start referring to this problem as endemic of sex-based male violence against women and girls, and femicide as opposed to “gender-based violence”. To be clear, this is a problem that affects females overwhelmingly. Unclear and ambiguous language hides the problem and makes it difficult to counter. For example, Statistics Canada changed the way it tracks crimes in 2017, recording crimes according to the accused and victim’s chosen, mutable “gender identity” instead of the immutable sex of those involved. This change has resulted in unclear data, skewed such that it makes it impossible to track accurate numbers in regards to the sex of perpetrators of violence against women and girls. Scotland has adopted a similar approach to statistics, and “as gender self-identification becomes more common, either by law or, as in Scotland, without legal change, there is evidence to suggest that failing to anticipate such abuse is naïve” (“Losing Sight of Women's Rights: The Unregulated Introduction of Gender Self-Identification as a Case Study of Policy Capture in Scotland”, p. 283). Skewed data obscures and derails ensuing political and financial support aimed at combating the problem. When one does not identify sex, one cannot combat sexism. In this case sexism comes in the form of femicide and male violence against women and girls. Criminal Justice Reforms In the Speech from the Crown, the Right Honourable Governor General references criminal reforms in the following manner: Canadians understand that equity, justice, and diversity are the means and the ends to living together. Fighting systemic racism, sexism, discrimination, misconduct, and abuse, including in our core institutions, will remain a key priority. The Government will also continue to reform the criminal justice system and policing. Women Matter Canada is concerned that these reforms may have a negative impact on females if recent years’ changes are not reviewed in a fulsome, honest manner, resulting in policy reversal in order to protect vulnerable, incarcerated females. Note that 5% of the population in federal prisons are women and 42% of those women are Indigenous. To combat racism, it is clear examination and reforms need to be made in order to change this over-representation of Indigenous women in federal prisons. Further, it is noted that “91 percent of indigenous women and 87 percent of all women in federal prisons in Canada have experienced physical or sexual abuse”(“Rising Incarceration Rates of Racialized Women”, p. 1). To combat the furthering of trauma for women trying to recover from abuse, women need proper protection from male violence while incarcerated. They deserve boundaries around their bodies that female-only space provides. In 2017 Correctional Services Canada (“CSC”) made an interim policy change in response to C-16 coming into force in the form of “Interim Policy Bulletin 584”. It is now almost 2022 and the policy still has neither been reviewed or put through Parliament. The Policy has resulted in removing the safeguards that had been put in place in the 1980’s when policy was created to allow the rare transfers into women’s prisons of convicted males who identified as women and who all had full genital surgery. As a result of the 2017 policy, prisoners no longer need to have sexual reassignment surgery (SRS), be on hormones, or have to go through a psychological evaluation. They needn’t even identify as women but can simply identify as “non-binary”. Since this interim policy has come into force, 58 known transfers have taken place, with 27 (46.6%) of those being offenders who have histories of violence against women or children, and these transfer numbers would not include those with a GRC (“Brief Submitted to the Standing Committee on Public Safety and National Security”, p. 11-14). Even transfers that are deemed too dangerous to be in women's prisons have been transferred. At least one inmate who had been convicted of brutal rape of a young child has been placed in a mother-child unit. There is mounting anecdotal evidence that female prisoners have been assaulted, sexually harassed, and feel genuinely unsafe with many of these transfers (“Brief Submitted to the Standing Committee on Public Safety and National Security”, p. 3-5). Further, currently there is one active case of a criminal proceeding against a transfer who had allegedly sexually assaulted a female prisoner in their shared living quarters (“Brief Submitted to the Standing Committee on Public Safety and National Security”, p. 3). An interesting note is there are no such transfers of female to male prisons because it is deemed too unsafe for those female prisoners. It is likely that the issue is affecting far more women than we know as there is evidence the system silences complaints: female prisoners who have attempted to use the complaint system about these problems have reported being threatened with having their paroles affected if they speak up (“Brief Submitted to the Standing Committee on Public Safety and National Security”, p. 8-9). It is time that an inquiry be held and these transfers be suspended until better framework is put in place to ensure appropriate, functioning safeguards for females are enacted. It is the contention of Women Matter Canada that incarcerated males do not belong in women’s prisons, and statistics need to be collected accurately. To combat sexism and abuse in criminal justice, Women Matter Canada calls on the Government of Canada to reverse the policy allowing incarcerated males who have not had full GRC to transfer into women’s prisons and calls for a full inquiry into this issue and the effects on females. To combat sexism in criminal justice, Women Matter Canada calls on Canada to gather and record accurate crime data listing the sex of both perpetrator and victim, as well as claimed “gender identity”. Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women and Girls It is paramount that the federal government promptly focus on and act on the issue of missing and murdered indigenous women and girls. The inaction on this decades-long tragedy is cruel, racist, and a disgrace on this country. Femicide is approximately 4.5 times more likely to happen to Indigenous women and girls than the rest of the female population in Canada (“Missing and murdered Indigenous women and girls: Understanding the numbers”). It is time to take meaningful, markable action on this serious problem and to report annually to the public on the results of those actions. Women Matter Canada calls on the Canadian government to have MMIWG be a focal point in reducing the over-representation of Indigenous women in the justice system, to action the suggestions in the MMIWG Reports immediately. And to include those actions as part of the 10 year strategy framework. Women Matter Canada calls for the Canadian government to and to publicly report on its specific actions and their results each and every year. Conclusion The fact that the government has made mention of violence against women and girls, criminal justice reforms, and missing and murdered Indigenous women and girls in the speech from the throne is an important first step in actively combating these three long-standing issues. We urge the government to take real action on these problems which have had increasingly negative impact on females in this country. We call on the government to:
Explicitly name and record femicide and male violence against Canadian females (women and girls);
To take identifiable, significant, and measurable actions to combat male violence;
To record, name, and track sex-based violence against women and girls;
To make changes to the reporting system in jails so abuse of inmates may be reported without fear of repercussions and reprimands;
To specifically focus on the matter of MMIWG by working to address the over-representation of Indigenous women in prison and by implementing suggestions in the MMIWG Reports; and,
To annually report publicly on the progress of each of these actions.
References “#CallItFemicide: Understanding sex/gender-related killings of women and girls in Canada, 2020”, Canadian Femicide Observatory for Justice and Accountability. Accessed at https://www.femicideincanada.ca/node/668 “Interim Policy Bulletin 584”, Correctional Services Canada (2017). Accessed at https://www.csc-scc.gc.ca/policy-and-legislation/584-pb-en.shtml Mason, Heather. Brief submitted to the Standing Committee on Public Safety and National Security on the Current situation in federal prisons in relation to reports of sexual coercion and violence in federal prisons (June 22, 2021). Accessed at https://drive.google.com/file/d/1b3UwWP8aDCFXM6988TkiBQ6Y8lbBwxhN/view “Missing and murdered Indigenous women and girls: Understanding the numbers”, Amnesty International (January 29, 2021). Accessed at https://www.amnesty.ca/blog/missing-and-murdered-indigenous-women-and-girls-understanding-the-numbers/ Murray, Kath and Blackburn, Lucy Hunter. “Losing Sight of Women's Rights: The Unregulated Introduction of Gender Self-Identification as a Case Study of Policy Capture in Scotland”, Scottish Affairs (2019), p. 262-289, Edinburgh University Press. Accessed at https://www.euppublishing.com/doi/pdfplus/10.3366/scot.2019.0284 Pate, Senator Kim. “Rising Incarceration Rates of Racialized Women” (Policy Briefing Note), Policy4Women (2018). Accessed at https://www.criaw-icref.ca/images/userfiles/files/P4W_BN_IncarcerationRacializedWomen_Accessible.pdf Additional Resources Academic Council on the United Nations System (ACUNS). 2017. Establishing a Femicide Watch in Every Country. Vienna: ACUNS. Academic Council on the United Nations System (ACUNS). 2013. Femicide: A Global Issue that Demands Action. Vienna: ACUNS. Allen, M. 2020. Crime reported by police serving areas where the majority of the population is Indigenous, 2018. Statistics Canada Catalogue no. 85-002-X. Ottawa, ON: Statistics Canada. Bensadoun, E. “Pandemic of violence’: Calls mount for recognition of misogyny in Nova Scotia shooting” Global News, April 27, 2020. https://globalnews.ca/news/6868709/nova-scotia-mass-shooting-femicide/ Bergeron, P. “Quebec Murderer Pleads Guilty to Killing Sex Worker While Out on Parole”, Huffington Post (February 27, 2020). Accessed at https://www.huffingtonpost.ca/entry/eustachio-gallese-sex-worker-killed-guilty mary lenelevesque_ca_ 5e58643a c5b6beedb4e8e864 Boyd, C., Sutton, D., Dawson, M., Straatman, A.L., Poon, J., Jaffe, P. 2020. Familicide in Canada: 2010-2019. Domestic Homicide Brief 9. London, ON: Canadian Domestic Homicide Prevention Initiative. ISBN: 978-1-988412-40-5. Brennan, S. “Violent Victimization of Aboriginal Women in the Canadian Provinces, 2009”, Statistics Canada (2011). Statistics Canada Catalogue no. 85-002-X. “Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against Women”, United Nations, 1979. https://www.un.org/womenwatch/daw/cedaw/cedaw.htm Hunter, Brad. “'Psychopathic' child sex killer uses trans card”, Toronto Sun (February 1, 2020) https://torontosun.com/news/world/hunter-psychopathic-child-sex-killer-uses-trans-card?fbclid=IwAR3N16AdRFJbr4IqzArplMZEi9i1K9K_bDMewMD1lDkQ89oWpfdys96CZC8 “The effect of C-16 on female penetentiaries”, Women Matter Canada (July 20, 2021). https://youtu.be/hK6md6lH0bw “The Final Report of the National Inquiry into Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women and Girls”, Volume 1A (June 2019). https://www.mmiwg-ffada.ca/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/Final_Report_Vol_1a-1.pdf “The Final Report of the National Inquiry into Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women and Girls”, Volume 1B (June 2019). https://www.mmiwg-ffada.ca/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/Final_Report_Vol_1b.pdf “United Nations Standard Minimum Rules for the Treatment of Prisoners”, United Nations (1955). https://www.hrw.org/legacy/advocacy/prisons/un-smrs.htm Wynter, Collin. “Conversation with Heather Mason”, Collin Wynter Channel (July 23, 2021). https://youtu.be/ER9MrRE9hOg